83 Monroe County Listings Expired in October. Most Had Already Cut Their Price.
By alexa • November 16, 2026

The Pocono Ledger | November 16, 2026
In October, 83 residential listings expired in Monroe County without selling, according to the Pocono MLS analysis. Of those, 53 had already reduced their asking price at least once. That raises an important question for Pocono homeowners: If lowering the price wasn't enough, what else kept those properties from selling?
What happened in the Monroe County housing market?
I reviewed the October residential listings reported as expired in the Pocono MLS and compared them with 206 closed-sale records included in the same analysis.
Three things stood out.
1. Most expired listings had already reduced their prices.
Of the 83 expired listings, 53 (64%) had at least one price reduction.
Among the 206 closed sales, 76 (37%) had reduced their asking prices.
That doesn't mean price reductions caused listings to expire. It means reducing the price wasn't enough to produce a sale for many of those properties.
2. Expired listings spent considerably longer on the market.
The median expired listing had been on the market for 173 days, compared with 36 days for the listings that sold.
That's a substantial difference.
And it raises another question: Were those properties priced incorrectly from the beginning, or were other factors making them difficult to sell?
3. Expired listings weren't limited to expensive homes.
The 83 expired listings were distributed across several price ranges:
Asking-price range, Expired listings,
Under $250,000 12
$250,000–$399,999 41
$400,000–$499,999 13
$500,000 and above 17
Total83
The largest number fell between $250,000 and $399,999.
That doesn't necessarily mean homes in this range were more likely to expire. We'd need to compare expiration rates across price ranges to establish that.
Why do Pocono homes expire without selling?
Price is an important factor, but it isn't the only one.
A home can struggle because of its condition, photographs, showing availability, financing challenges, location or competition from similar properties.
In the Poconos, property-specific issues can also matter. A buyer considering a home with a private well, septic system, aging roof or community restrictions may have concerns that a small price reduction won't resolve. And timing matters.
When a listing spends months on the market, buyers may begin asking why it hasn't sold. That doesn't automatically mean something is wrong with the property, but it can create additional questions that the seller and listing agent need to address.
A price reduction is a strategy only when it addresses the reason buyers aren't making offers.
What does this mean for Monroe County homeowners?
The broader market still had buyers.
The Pocono Mountains Association of REALTORS® reported 203 closed sales in October 2026, with a median sale price of $350,000.
The separate MLS analysis used for this article included 206 closed-sale records. These totals come from different reporting datasets and should not be treated as interchangeable.
The takeaway is that homes were selling, but not every property attracted a buyer during its listing period.
For homeowners preparing to sell in Stroudsburg, East Stroudsburg, Bartonsville, Tannersville or elsewhere in Monroe County, understanding your competition is essential.
And if your listing recently expired, putting the same property back on the market without reviewing what happened may not improve the outcome.
What should sellers do before listing or relisting?
Start with the competition. Look at the homes buyers can purchase today, not just what similar properties sold for six months ago.
Pay attention to the first few weeks. Showing activity, buyer feedback and competing listings can help identify problems early. No offers doesn't automatically prove the price is wrong, but it is a reason to investigate.
Diagnose before reducing. If buyers are touring the home but not making offers, find out why. If they're not scheduling showings, examine the price, presentation, marketing and accessibility.
Make meaningful changes before relisting. Depending on the property, that could mean adjusting the price, completing repairs, improving photographs or changing the marketing approach.
Is it a bad time to sell a house in the Poconos?
Not necessarily.
October's market activity shows that properties continued to sell even as other listings expired.
The question isn't simply whether buyers are out there.
It's whether your home is positioned to compete for the buyers looking in your price range.
And that's a conversation worth having before your listing spends six months on the market.
Thinking about selling in Monroe County, or wondering why your previous listing didn't sell? I can review your property's pricing, competition and presentation to help identify what deserves attention before your next move.
Sources and methodology: Pocono MLS / Flexmls, Monroe County residential listings with expiration dates October 1–31, 2026 (83), and closed-sale records dated October 1–31, 2026 (206 after excluding one record flagged for an apparent price error). Analysis dated November 16, 2026. Withdrawn and canceled listings were excluded. MLS listing counts may include separate listing records for the same property. Countywide market totals and median sale price are attributed separately to the Pocono Mountains Association of REALTORS® October 2026 Monthly Indicators. MLS figures are from the supplied research packet and have not been independently reproduced from raw records.
Alexa Sanchez, REALTOR®
PA License RS326383
Smart Way America Realty
528 Seven Bridges Rd, Suite 108
East Stroudsburg, PA 18301
(570) 688-8147
Thinking about selling your Pocono home?
Let’s find out what it’s worth before you make your next move.
The Pocono Insider
Discover the best things to do in the Poconos, from local events and hidden gems to restaurants and weekend adventures. Delivered to your inbox every week.
Contact Us
We will get back to you as soon as possible.
Please try again later.
SHARE THIS












